Rosenstein & Söhne Cake Pop Maker

Test 08/2019

  • Rosenstein & Söhne Cake Pop Maker - front
  • Rosenstein & Söhne Cake Pop Maker - front2
  • Rosenstein & Söhne Cake Pop Maker - front3
  • Rosenstein & Söhne Cake Pop Maker - right
  • Rosenstein & Söhne Cake Pop Maker - boxed
  • Rosenstein & Söhne Cake Pop Maker - detail
Test seal: Rosenstein & Söhne Cake Pop Maker, Rating 8.1

last modified: 08.10.2019, 10:43

We test independently. uses affiliate links. For a purchase via a link marked with a or our price comparison, we may receive a small commission.

All rating criteria details:

Handling 20%
Safety 20%
Speed 20%
Workmanship 20%
Cleaning 10%
Overall impression 10%
Tested by: Jana


Product tester


The Cake Pop Maker by Rosenstein & Söhne is a solid device, which unfortunately is not very convincing in quality. The device looks unstable and also the shape of the baked cake pops resembles round balls only to a limited extend. Nevertheless, the device bakes cake pops in a very short time and you can definitely eat them.


  • Short baking time
  • Simple operation


  • Lots of smoke during the baking time
  • The device may appear very unstable in some cases
  • Frequently deformed results due to loose cover

360° View

A device with simple operation and short baking time, but often with deformed results and slight smoke formation during baking.

The device

The Cakepop-Maker by Rosenstein & Söhne comes in a simple design. The first impression of this device is ok, but it looks a bit unstable because the lid is loosely fastened. With this Cake-Pop-Maker, you can prepare 12 cake pops.

In the scope of delivery are:

  • Device
  • Instruction


Before the first use, you should clean the baking tray of this appliance with a damp cloth and only then grease it with butter, margarine or baking fat and connect it to the mains. This cake pop maker needs approx. 3 minutes to heat up. When the ideal operating temperature is reached, the green light illuminates. With the help of a teaspoon or a piping bag, you can add the dough to the baking tray. A recipe from the instructions was used for the dough used in the test:

Vanilla cake pops:

  • 125 g flour
  • 1/2 teaspoon baking powder
  • 1 small pinch of salt
  • 125 g butter
  • 100 g sugar
  • 2 eggs
  • 1 tsp vanilla extract
  • Glaze to decorate as desired

When adding the dough, it is important not to pour too much dough into the baking trays. The baking time is about 4-6 minutes. When performing the test, it was noticeable that a lot of smoke came out of the appliance, especially during the first rounds. Even after several procedures, it did not become less. In addition, the dough oozed out on the side, although special care was taken to ensure that little dough was added to the baking tray recesses.

Cake pops with the Cake Pop Maker by Rosenstein & Söhne
Cake pops with the Cake Pop Maker by Rosenstein & Söhne

According to the manufacturer, the baking time is approx. 4 minutes, which was also roughly measured in the test procedure. However, the indicator lights here do not indicate when the cake pops are ready - the indicator lights only serve to indicate when the appliance is ready to heat up.

The result of the cake pops is satisfactory. They often don't look like real balls but have an oval shape.

Despite the heat-insulated handle, it gets very hot and can only be opened with a baking glove. Since the whole appliance gets very hot, you have to wait about 30 minutes to be able to clean it.


The appliance or the baking trays are not dishwasher-safe and must, therefore, be cleaned with a damp cloth.

We have evaluated about 70 customer reviews on the Internet. In summary, it can be said that about 90 percent of buyers are satisfied (4 stars) or even very satisfied (5 stars). Partially (2 stars) or completely dissatisfied are approx. 5 percent of the users. The average score at the time of the evaluation was 4.5 out of 5 stars.

Summary: 90% positive and 5% negative ratings

The following points were often positively noted:

  • Easy and fast handling
  • Great result, with an enclosed recipe
  • Easy cleaning

The following points were often negatively noted:

  • Difficult to dose the dough correctly - no round result
  • Poor workmanship
Manufacturer Rosenstein & Söhne
EAN 4022107217545
Scope of delivery Device, operating instructions
Quality impression Good
Differences in thermal energy Baking time (lid up to 88 degrees, edge up to 138 degrees hot)
Additional warranty No Information
Height 10 cm
Width 20 cm
Depth 24.5 cm
Weight 1636 g
Cooling time Approx. 30 min.
Duration Approx. 6 min.
Power 729 W
Heating time Approx. 3 min.
Readiness indicator Yes (green/red lamp)
Temperature levels No
Dishwasher safe No
Incl. sticks No
Incl. recipe recommendations Yes
Control lamps Yes (red/ green)
Non-slip feet No
Heat insulating handle Yes
Packaging Good
Manual language GER, FR
Quality of instructions Good
Overall impression

Our winner

All products

Check our main page to get an overview of all tested products within this category.

Overview: Cake Pop Maker

How do you like this product?


How big are the finished cake pops?
They have a diameter of approx. 3.5 cm.
Are the plates removable?
No, the plates are fixed to the device and cannot be removed.


No comments

Ask George or leave a comment

E-mail address and name are optional


Matching accessories for this item

  • B00EEG2ZA4
  • B00T71CI6M
  • B010NFDP4E

Other products of this manufacturer

  • B000KU3ZMK
  • B00349ZEF0
  • B0068MUQYY